Are You a Success?

July 21st, 2010

“Success is the progressive realization of a worthy goal,” a definition coined by motivational speaker and author Earl Nightingale, which is widely used today in coaching and development programs.  While most people agree that goals are important, less than five percent write down goals or have action plans to attain them, according to OPEN Small Business NetworkSM.

Your business and your life are going to be pretty much the same a year from now unless you expand your thinking to attain something greater.

If you are a small businessman, perhaps your goal is a large new client that matches your ideal client profile.  You don’t have an ideal client profile?  Make that your first goal.

If you provide skilled services, your goal might be to add another, or improve on one at which you already excel.

Goals must be specific, measureable and have a time component.

Like any businessman, I’d like to see my business grow, because only a growing business can survive.  But that is not specific enough.  Our goal is to add one new client per quarter.  It is specific, measureable and within a time frame. 

Goals also must be realistic.  I wouldn’t want a new client every month, because we couldn’t provide the level of service with existing staff, and wouldn’t have time to properly train and integrate new employees into the agency.

If you’ve ever worked with goals, you know they can take on a life of their own, just by committing them to paper.  One self-help teacher advocates writing down your top ten desires on a sheet of paper, then checking back a year later to see how many have been achieved.  Participants are often astounded at what transpires with little or no effort.  A colleague remarked how his wife, who had never flown in an airplane, wrote down that desire on her “wish list.”  Within six months, she was on an expense-paid visit to relatives, and remarked to her husband in the airplane, “Wow, that really works.”

Our agency is in the business of turning creative ideas into something tangible, like a printed piece, outdoor billboard, website, or special event.  Those things evolve by committing ideas to paper, or electronic file, and nurturing them into reality.  They follow the goal process.

When was the last time you used your creative process to benefit your business or yourself, rather than your client or customer?  It merely takes an idea shaped into a goal.

If you want to achieve more success in your business or your personal life, remember the admonition of Max Depree, “We cannot become what we need to be, remaining what we are.”

Set some worthwhile goals.  You’ll likely be surprised at your progressive success.

Continue the blog and share how goal-setting has impacted your career or personal life.

–Ralph Yearick

  • Share/Bookmark

A Tale of Three Restaurants (Or, training versus development)

June 19th, 2010

I was invited one evening to dine at a high-end seafood restaurant with a client who wanted to do a working dinner with an out-of-town consultant.

While I had eaten at this restaurant on other occasions, on this particular visit I was spell-bound by the quality of service from a young African-American waitress who exuded confidence and competency in delivering a fine meal.  Even the act of pouring water was a ritual of removing each stemmed glass from the table, placing it on a small circular tray in her left hand and pouring the iced water from a large crystal pitcher in her right hand.  There was a real sense of showmanship in her delivery of the product.  No detail was overlooked.  Her level of service was perfect – not too many interruptions, and not leaving us wanting for anything.  This occurred on a Monday evening and I was surprised to look around the restaurant and see every table filled.  Certainly, no effects of the dire economy there.  People were more than willing to pay a high price for excellent food and outstanding service.

A day or two later, I was attempting to have a mid-morning meal at a family restaurant chain noted for their breakfast offerings.  The hostess was quick to seat me at a table that had just been cleaned.  The paper placemat was plopped down in front of me and quickly adhered to the very wet surface.  She then dropped the silverware, wrapped up tightly in the paper napkin, not onto the placemat but onto the wet table.

When she brought me the coffee and water I had requested, she was carrying both in one hand and promptly spilled them onto the middle of the table.  She just laughed.  I responded, “This is not acceptable.”  She laughed again.  I mentioned the wet table, and she countered, “but it’s clean.”  I again repeated that it was “not acceptable.”  I said, “Your restaurant touts a quality experience, but this is not quality.”  At this point, other diners around us had turned their ears to listen in on the dialogue.  I arose and repeated again, “This is not acceptable.”  And walked away.  Her jaw dropped.

I drove three miles to another local family chain and was promptly seated at a table that had a number of pieces of trash on the floor beneath it.  I was pretty hungry at that point, so just ignored it.  When I went to pay the cashier, the silent, stoic gal behind the register had no comment at all.  I asked, “Aren’t you supposed to ask me how my meal was?”  Her eyes widened in shock.  She sheepishly responded, “How was everything?”  I related how the food was okay, but was surprised that I was seated at a table with a lot of trash beneath it.  She just laughed and said, “It’s so hard to keep up with.”  And that was the end of the conversation.

Being a marketer, I take the time to give feedback on my various experiences, as I would want the same feedback on my clients’ products and services.  I emailed the customer relations departments of both food chains, merely stating that “workers need to be properly trained.”  I also asked that they not send a follow-up letter or discount coupons for another visit, but to give better service to their other future clients, which would not include me.

One of the restaurants sent coupons.  The other emailed me for more feedback, but that wasn’t necessary as they had a full description of my experience in my original email.  All they had to do was act on it.  Both mentioned that they would be contacting area training personnel. 

I was relating these experiences to a business development colleague and he reminded me of a metaphoric question often asked by David Byrd, president of Leadership Management, Inc.:

Fresh paint sometimes looks good on a metal surface without a primer coat, so why waste your time with a primer coat?”

He admonishes that a primer coat of paint takes time, investment, and work, but it protects the finish coat from rust over the long term.

This illustration points out the big difference between training and development.  You can teach an employee a process such as clearing a table or ringing up a cash register, or you can develop an employee to think about how they can improve the process over the long term.  At the seafood restaurant, it was quite obvious the young woman had not just been trained; she had been empowered to think about every aspect of the delivery process and adjust it for continuous improvement.

So what are you doing in your business?  Are you training your employees to do tasks, or are you developing them to assume responsibility for doing the tasks in the most professional, most cost-effective and most timely manner?  If the latter, then you are a leader.  Leaders develop.  Trainers train.  In retrospect, I should have told the two restaurants that the employees needed proper “development,” rather than “training.”

In the next few days, be alert to the levels of service you receive in business and personal transactions.  You will readily notice the difference between a worker who has been trained and one who has been developed.  

If you are in a managerial position, assess whether you are training or developing your employees, and whether the technique is creating more or less value for your business.

If you are not in a supervisory position, look at areas of your job where you could assume more responsibility for improving a product or process.  A progressive organization will recognize and reward you for your increased efforts. 

Continue the blog and share how empowering an employee or assuming self-empowerment has resulted in a more positive outcome for you or your business. 

–Ralph Yearick

  • Share/Bookmark

Are You Too Busy Sawing?

May 19th, 2010

Stephen Covey, in his book, The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People, starts the final chapter with a short story:

Suppose you were to come upon someone in the woods working feverishly to saw down a tree.

 “What are you doing?” you ask.

“You look exhausted!” you exclaim.  “How long have you been at it?”

“Over five hours,” he returns, “and I’m beat.  This is hard work.”

“Well, why don’t you take a break for a few minutes and sharpen that saw?” you inquire.  “I’m sure it would go a lot faster.” 

“I don’t have time to sharpen the saw,” the man says emphatically.  “I’m too busy sawing!”

How many of us are too busy in our day-to-day business to take the time to “sharpen the saw”?  What does that mean?  It means taking a fresh look at what we do, how we do it, and how we could do it better – whether that is more efficiently, more cost-effectively, with higher quality, or with more creativity.  We get stuck in our comfort zones because they are simply that – “comfortable.”

When was the last time you looked at your business with fresh eyes?  Maybe you’re too close to the work to see it.  Maybe you “hire” a fresh set of eyes to look at your business.

That’s what I did three months ago.  I hired a business coach.  In a short period of time, we’ve addressed some major issues that we had been putting off for years.  We have a new strategic plan, revised mission statement, new business development process, reorganized client servicing structure, increased communication at all levels of the company, and we’re moving toward a long-term succession plan.  I can’t wait to see what the next three months will bring.

Sharpening the saw is about getting out of our ruts and making every day a new day in business.  It’s not at all comfortable, but it creates some dramatic changes.

There’s another maxim about a retiring teacher who was asked how long he had been at the profession.  He replied that he had taught 20 years.  He is then questioned as to whether he taught 20 years, or he taught one year 20 times.  I actually had that latter experience at a well known university where the professor was using the exact same class notes for at least ten years.  We had only four students in our class, so he photocopied his 3”x5” cards (ask your parents what they were for) and distributed them to us at each class.  Many times the dates on the cards coincided with the exact same date of the lecture, only with a 10-year difference.  This was a man who was teaching the same year throughout his career.  It was a technology course, and a good thing that technology wasn’t changing much back then.  It related to the printing industry and much of it is not recognizable today.

So how are you making every new client project a “fresh” project?  When was the last time you took a continuing education course, read a marketing or design book, looked at consumer trends, asked about social networking goals, looked for “a horse to ride” (Al Ries and Jack Trout), sat through a Webinar, or just went networking at your local professional association meeting? There are countless ways to “sharpen the saw.”

Sometimes we just become “stuck.”  When that occurs, don’t be afraid to ask for help, get a jump-start, or sometimes a good ‘ol fashioned kick in the rear end.  A new perspective can make business a lot more fun, not to mention more profitable.

Continue the blog and share how you have kept your skills fresh, your work sharp and your talents creative.  Or share a time when you got “stuck” and found a way to turn it around. 

–Ralph Yearick

  • Share/Bookmark

Another Metaphor: Is Time Money?

April 21st, 2010

Most people have heard the metaphor that “time is money.”  But what does that mean – time is money?

About 20 years ago, I heard Charles Faulkner, noted Neuro-Linguistic Programming author, developer and trainer, talk about the metaphors of business.  “Time is money” is a big one according Faulkner, who claimed it had only been around about 150 years.  So fast forward to today, and it’s been around about 170 years.

He traced its embrace to the early days of the railroads in the United States.  Train tracks suddenly appeared in isolated towns and villages, linking the outposts to urban centers.  Regular train stops provided many needed goods from far away locations, as well as a way to move farm crops to markets where they could be sold for a profit.

History has it that Richard Warren Sears, a railroad station agent in Minnesota, received a large shipment of watches from a Chicago jeweler, which were unwanted by a local jeweler.  Sears purchased them himself, sold the watches for a tidy profit to other station agents up and down the line, and then ordered more for resale.  Sears would later partner with Alvah Roebuck, to create Sears, Roebuck and Company.

Time became a valuable commodity.   Trains ran on schedules.  If a trader wasn’t on time to meet the train, he missed an opportunity to buy or sell goods.  Time became money.  People on the prairies could no longer look to the height of the sun in the sky to determine the time of day.  They needed more precise time-keeping methods, such as watches and clocks, so they wouldn’t end up missing the train.

Time and money have definable traits.  Time has numerical units.  It can be tied to an exchange rate, and in doing so, it becomes valuable.  Money also has units.  As a commodity, it can be exchanged for a certain amount of time, goods or services.  We aren’t at choice about money.  We need it for survival as we live in complex societies.  When people save it, it becomes an object.  When it is scarce, people want more.  Money can offer a sense of security.

In my work, time is definitely money.  I bill my services by the hour.  In fact, our agency bills in 15-minute increments.  (Some law firms bill in six-minute increments.)  When friends or associates ask how our firm makes money, I tell them that we sell hours.  There’s an old saying that successful people do things other people don’t like to do.  Our philosophy is a bit broader.  We exchange creative services for money from clients who don’t have the expertise to do the things we do, don’t like to do the tasks we do, or don’t have the time to do them.  They can gain time by exchanging money for it.  Which leads to another metaphor – “money is time.”

Years ago, I read a business advisor’s advice to pay for services you can do yourself when you can buy them at a lower hourly rate than you charge for your services.  Then you are saving the value of your time.  For instance, if you can hire someone to clean your house for $10 an hour, and you bill your services at $75 an hour, then you are buying time.  Money becomes time.  You can fritter away the time or invest it in more money making.

Time is one commodity that everyone has an equal amount of.  Whether wealthy or poor, everyone has the exact same amount of time.  It’s how we choose to spend it.  Time, like money, is spendable.

Faulkner, who has made a living out of studying metaphors, says that when you shift your metaphor about money to “energy,” then you suddenly seem to have more of it.  So if we reverse the metaphor to “energy is money,” that gives a new way to look at being more successful in our businesses.  If we put more energy into our work, we’ll likely be rewarded with more money.

What are your metaphors for time, money or energy?  Do they support you in your daily business activities?  If your metaphor is the old “Money is the root of all evil,” then it may be time to find one that is more positive and supportive to demonstrating success in business.

Continue the blog and share how your metaphors are supporting you or may be holding you back.  As Charles Faulkner reminds us, “We can’t not think metaphorically.”  Choose your metaphors consciously.

–Ralph Yearick

  • Share/Bookmark

Is War Your Metaphor for Business?

April 1st, 2010

Every grade school student learns the difference between a metaphor and simile in their basic reading and writing classes.  But are you aware that metaphors shape our perceptions of how we respond to business and life?

“We can’t not think metaphorically,” according to Charles Faulkner, a noted Neuro Linguistic Programming (NLP) writer and trainer.  His premise is that most businesses operate from a particular metaphor and that it’s pretty easy to determine by walking through a company’s headquarters.  Some of the more popular metaphors for business are:  family, game, machine, and organism.

I had an opportunity to study with Faulkner a couple decades ago.  Here is a simple chart he shared on how these metaphors can play out in a business:

Business Metaphors Family Game Machine Organism
Desired States

Togetherness

Security

Stability

Continuity

Support

WinningFun

Excitement

Challenge

Skill

Participation

ProductivityEfficiency

Dependable

Interchangeable

LivingGrowing

Nitch

Reproduction

Food

Values  LoveHonesty

Fidelity

Trust

Respect

Community

PlayfulnessLearning

Cooperation

Competition

Integrity

DependabilityTime Saving

Quality

RenewalSurvival

Growth

Adaptation

Beliefs

Participation in something larger

Play certain roles

Family/Non-family

Significance

Challenge

Winning is good

Playing or not

Necessary part

Must serve

Replaceable

Consume to survive

Survival of the fittest

Interdependence

Reproduction

Death

 

You can discover a person’s metaphors by observing their language, hearing their goals, watching their actions and looking at their “artifacts” (their clothing, office decorations, etc.).

Faulkner suggests that man’s metaphors evolved through the stages of family, game, machine (corporation), to society/culture.  And within that last stage is “war.”  We all know someone whose metaphor for business is war.  They tend to make comments about business being a battlefield, rallying the troops, getting shot down, or protecting one’s turf.

If war happens to be your metaphor for business, you might enjoy reading The Art of War.  An MBA professor at a nationally recognized school of business recommends the book to all her students.  Compiled more than 2,000 years ago by a mysterious warrior-philosopher named Sun Tzu, this Chinese classic is considered by many to be the most prestigious and influential book on strategy in the world today.  This professor obviously relates to business in the war metaphor.

The Art of War is about dealing with conflict as it abounds everywhere in business and life.  The Chinese strategy is to deal with conflict wisely, honorably, and victoriously.  This treatise studies the anatomy of organizations in conflict.  Its ideas can be applied to every level from the interpersonal to the international, and are reportedly studied in Asia by modern politicians and business executives.

As I read The Art of War, I was able to apply these ideas to my business, and also see their broader applications to world politics and recent armed conflict strategies.  For instance, if the past presidential administration had understood these concepts, we likely would not be fighting two wars today.  Similarly, in my opinion, if the long-term implications of the recent healthcare strategy had been fully analyzed according to considerations in The Art of War, the resulting bill would have been quite different.

The Art of War aims at invincibility, victory without battle and unassailable strength through understanding the physics, politics and psychology of conflict.

Even if your current metaphor for running your business is not the war metaphor, The Art of War is still a good read.  In doing business, you will have conflict with your customers, your employees, your vendors and, at times, your family.  The Art of War gives you the perspective to step back, analyze the conflict and see a more positive strategy for resolution.  As Newsweek so boldy declared, “Absorb this book and you can throw out all those contemporary books about management leadership.”  I tend to agree.  These 2,000-year-old ideas are timeless.

Look around your own business and see what metaphors tend to govern your day-to-day meetings, conversations and visuals.  As Charles Faulkner mentioned when he walked into a corporate headquarters and found medieval armor in the lobby, “They clearly operated from a war metaphor.”  He went on to note that the autographed footballs in one president’s office were a tipoff to business as sport.  According to Faulkner, Andrew Carnegie’s metaphor was:  “Business is the greatest game of all.”

Continue the blog and share what metaphor your company operates from.  And peruse a copy of The Art of War.

  • Share/Bookmark

Are We Having Fun Yet?

February 24th, 2010

I was shoveling my driveway recently from the February snow storms when a neighborhood jogger ran past and asked, “Are we having fun yet?”, a saying coined by cartoonist Bill Griffith in the late 1970s for his comic strip character Zippy the Pinhead.  I was more than surprised to look up and see a crazy man running down the street in his spandex outfit; but once I recovered, my response was a quick smile and a simple, “Yes.”

A few days later I was roaming through my book shelf and found some ten-year-old notes from a talk by motivational speaker and author Harvey Mackay, while he was leading an American Marketing Association meeting in Pittsburgh.  There were just 10 lines on the sheet — the distillation of a morning-long program.  They obviously were significant because I realized I had incorporated many of them into my everyday business practices.

Near the bottom of the list was one sentence with a star before it:  “Put some fun and creativity into your life and your business!”

Not many business gurus talk about fun in the workplace.  Steven Covey, famous for his book, The 7 Habits of Highly Successful People, admonishes that there are four basic needs of every individual:  to live, to love, to learn, and to leave a legacy.  The four L’s.  I’ve been meaning to write Covey a letter and suggest that a good fifth L would be to laugh.

Laughing comes with having fun.  Stone-faced Covey didn’t seem to acknowledge that having fun can lead to being more creative and profitable.

When I had a mid-life career shift and joined an advertising agency, I was suddenly thrown into brainstorming meetings for client ads.  Our creative skills were put to task to come up with ways to communicate the clients’ unique selling points in memorable ways.  There was a great synergy in sitting around a table shooting ideas into the air.  We laughed a lot and, as a result, put out some great work.

The ad agency was such a refreshing change from my previous position that my friends would casually remark to new acquaintances, “Don’t ask him what he does.”  For those who were willing to chance it, I replied, “I’M AN ADVERTISING MAN.  And they even PAY me to do it.”

Needless to say I was having fun.

The years have rolled by and I’ve worked at times among a more sober bunch.  At one point I recognized our corporate culture as being too serious for a creative team.  The laughs needed to be more frequent, so I started working on it.  The staff looked at me oddly when I told them to have a joke ready to start the staff meeting.  We had a few laughs over it and over the joke, too.

At another point, we even instituted the position of Fun Officer, who was responsible for planning employee activities.  One of the perks was her “fun” budget, a minor expense compared to the value we received in staff teambuilding.

So here’s the question, “Are you having fun yet?”  Because if you aren’t, your work will be mediocre and marginal.  Your message will be functional but lifeless.  And hardly memorable, which doesn’t satisfy our needs as marketers.

I recently sent a congratulatory email to a client who had just been promoted to a new branding role in his company.  His one-statement reply was “Thanks.  It might be fun, too.”

With that attitude, I know he’s going to do a great job.

Harvey Mackay’s challenge to “put some fun and creativity into your life and your business” is one that requires a conscious choice.  When you look for ways to do it, you’ll find them.

Continue the blog and share how adding some fun in your job or workplace has produced a better ad, a more memorable trade show, a superior employee outing, or some other positive outcome.

–Ralph Yearick

  • Share/Bookmark

2 of the 22 Immutable Laws of Marketing

February 17th, 2010

More from Al Ries and Jack Trout….

In 1994, they wrote The 22 Immutable Laws of Marketing: Violate Them at Your Own Risk!. If you haven’t read them, they still hold up well after 16 years.

Rule Number 1 is the Law of Leadership.  It is better to be first than it is to be better.

They assert that many people believe that the basic issue in marketing is to convince prospects that you have a better product or service.  In reality they conclude, the basic issue in marketing is creating a category you can be first in.

Examples include Xerox, Coke, Band-Aid, Krazy Glue, Saran Wrap and FedEx, among others.  Brands tend to remain leaders because their names became generic.

So what do you do if you can’t be “first”?  Go to Rule Number 2:  The Law of Category.  If you can’t be first in a category, set up a new category you can be first in.

Ries and Trout point out that this is counter to classis marketing thinking, which is brand-oriented.  “Forget the brand,” they admonish.  “Think categories.”  Prospects are on the defensive when it comes to brands.  Everyone talks about how their brand is better.  But prospects have an open mind when it comes to categories.  Everyone’s interested in what is new.  Few are interested in what’s better.

They point out that after World War II, Heineken was the first beer to make a name for itself in America.  Four decades later, it was the No. 1 imported beer.  Competitor Anheuser-Busch could have said, “We should bring in an imported beer, too.”  Instead, they said, “If there’s a market for a high-priced imported beer, there must be a market for a high-priced domestic beer, too.”  Anheuser introduced Michelob, the first high-priced domestic beer, which soon outsold Heineken two-to-one.

We have an industrial client who already has significant market share for their products because they innovated many of the market standards.  Studies show they are often first-in-mind with prospective specifiers.  But they aren’t content to just rest on being “first.”  They are establishing new categories for their products, positioning them as “green” solutions and leaders in the solar market.

Few can be first to market, but many can lead a category.  How might you reposition your product or service by finding a new category you can be first in?

  • Share/Bookmark

Checked Your Research Lately?

January 6th, 2010

I’ve had clients who wouldn’t spend money on basic customer research. That’s like trying to plan a driving trip from Denver to New York and being too cheap to buy a road map. You wouldn’t even know in which direction to start off.

My first introduction to market research was shortly after college when I joined the marketing department of a member-supported research foundation, whose purpose was to help companies in the printing industry do their jobs better.

I worked for a crusty old marketing boss who would dictate what programs and services the foundation offered to its members.  Being a brash young upstart, I asked him one day, “How do we know this is what our members want and need.”  He looked at me, pointed his index finger to his temple, tapped it several times, and said, “Intuitive marketing.”  To which I replied, “So we’re just guessing.”

Needless to say, I didn’t work there much longer.

Years later, I was sitting around a conference table in Atlanta with a bunch of association executives from the hardwood industry, who were looking for ways to get builders of custom homes to specify more North American hardwoods.  I asked them what builders needed to specify the product.  They collectively answered that builders needed glossy pictures of hardwood installations to show to prospective homebuyers.  I asked them how they knew that.

Suddenly I had a déjà vu experience when one of the old-timers starting tapping his temple and saying, “We’ve been in this industry a long time.  We know what they need.”

So I asked if we might conduct a research project “just to confirm” their position.

After interviewing 400 builders across the country, we learned that the single-most deterrent to specifying North American hardwoods was the high cost of scrap.  If a worker miss-cut a piece of hardwood, or a finisher botched the paint or stain job, they were left with mighty expensive scrap.  Hence they tended to specify less costly soft woods, like pine.

What we also learned was that builders wanted technical information on installing hardwoods and finishing them on site.

That one piece of information directed the hardwood marketing program for several years through a series of technical publications called Tips & Techniques:  For builders and architects working with North American hardwood millwork, flooring and cabinetry.

The value of good market research may be that it confirms what you already know about how your customers or potential customers relate to your products or services.  Or, it just might turn up that one unexpected idea that can reshape your whole marketing approach.  Either way, it tells you if you’re on track or not.

Expensive research projects still have their place.  But inexpensive research can easily be conducted today through internet software such as Survey Monkey or Constant Contact.

Successful marketing is when you know what your customers want and need, and then develop or tailor products and services to meet those customer needs.  Market research provides the road map.

Add to the blog and share some unexpected insight you learned from your market research.

–Ralph Yearick

  • Share/Bookmark

Cash in Trash

December 15th, 2009

I’m a great fan of author Harvey McKay (Swim with the Sharks). He ran an envelope factory and couldn’t seem to make a profit. So he went to an industry meeting and one evening found an old successful envelope printer from another part of the country sitting at a bar smoking a cigar. Harvey approached him and said, “I gotta ask you. How do you make any money in this business?”

The guy took a swig of his drink, drew in a good puff on the stogie and asked, “What do you get for your scrap?”

To which Harvey replied, “Excuse me?”

“Scrap, scrap; what do you get per ton for your scrap paper?”

Harvey explained that he paid to have his scrap hauled away. He suddenly had an AH-HA moment, realizing there was an over-looked profit center in the scrap paper. He finished his story by saying he returned home and was able to undercut his competitors’ deals because he had a new profit center in the company.

There are two morals to this story: Find ways to turn a liability into an asset. And, learn from other successful people in your industry. If you travel long distances to find a mentor, like at a national convention, it likely means you won’t be geographic competitors, and a successful person is usually more than happy to tell you how they became so successful.

Add to the blog and tell us how you’ve learned from other successful people in your industry.

–Ralph Yearick

  • Share/Bookmark

Find a Horse to Ride

December 3rd, 2009

Two of my favorite marketers are Al Ries and Jack Trout, authors of Positioning: The Battle for Your Mind and Marketing Warfare.

One concept they espoused was “find a horse to ride.” Basically, it involves tying your product or service into another product or service that can broaden your reach.

There are many great marketing examples of this. Dairy Queen promotes popular candy bars and cookies in their Blizzard product. XM radio teams with automakers to have their radios installed in new automobiles, virtually assuring them a new customer after the 90-day free trial period expires. The movie production houses promote their new releases through tie-ins with fast food companies such as McDonald’s or Burger King.

I once advised a small business owner who sold bookkeeping services to team up with other vendors who provided similar businesses, such as payroll or temporary staffing. He enjoyed good success.

I also knew an industrial water meter salesman who teamed up with an industrial piping salesman. Each covered the same territories, so during sales pitches, they casually mentioned the other’s product and promoted it as superior to other brands. When the other salesman made his next call, he already had a favorable reference and usually wrote up an order on the spot.

While the concept is well proven, the trick is finding the right horse to ride. In the early 1990’s, McDonald’s did a tie-in with Warner Bros. in promoting their new movie, “Batman Returns.” During the promotion, customers purchasing a McDonald’s Happy Meal received one of several premiums, such as Batman in the Batmobile vehicle, along with figurines of archvillains Catwoman and Penguin. Unfortunately for McDonald’s, “Batman Returns” had been assigned the PG-13 rating, which encourages parental guidance for children more than 13 years of age. The film merited a PG-13 rating code as a result of its graphic scenes of electrocution, kidnapping and random gunfire.

The figurines were packed in Happy Meals and advertised as safe for children 1 year old and up. But they were designed to promote a movie created for viewers 13 years of age and over. The target age group was incongruent with the product tie-in. Teens weren’t eating Happy Meals, and toddlers weren’t viewing PG-13 movies.

McDonald’s took some flak from a Christian organization and had to issue an apology.

The promotion deal likely was made even before the movie was completed. And how would a marketing rep ever see a cartoon character, like Batman, as something less than wholesome.

Moral of the story: Like in any race, choose your horse carefully.

–Ralph Yearick

  • Share/Bookmark